Original Post — Direct link

I posted this as a reply to the Magic Dragon Challenge post, and someone suggested I make it a new post, in regards to the unbalanced way these contests are executed and the inherent streamer exploits which result in unfair outcomes.

Mediatonic's response is here, and my follow-up is here.

Here's an example of this contest and the huge advantage streamers were once again given; in this case, especially due to the private lobby feature. The first time the dragon became available it was a similar situation, a contest which one streamer won, while 2 other streamers were gifted the dragon, though they did not win the contest themselves.

When someone mentioned their concern about this issue on Twitter ,

Fall guys responded with "It's supposed to be really difficult - we want to keep the costume rare* and we don't want the number of entries to be too big as we have to manually go through and verify them all. Nobody has abused custom lobbies for this yet!" And they made the claim more than once that no streamer had used private lobbies for the contest.

So here's proof.

https://www.twitch.tv/videos/905478506?t=00h41m13s

41:52 to 45:40

Explains what he's going to do, why he's going to do it (because "it's really difficult" in regular lobbies), and how it's going to work. Says he will gift 25 subs for helping him get all three, or 20 for two. He also makes a deal with a viewer who said they will gift subs to his stream in exchange for second dibs on Bert.

https://www.twitch.tv/videos/905478506?t=01h23m14s the Fall Ball "win"

https://www.twitch.tv/videos/905478506?t=01h47m21s 1:47:21 to 1:50:40

More explanation of what he's doing and gift sub priority deals.

https://www.twitch.tv/videos/905478506?t=03h02m31s Perfect Match "win"

https://www.twitch.tv/videos/905478506?t=03h08m28s to 3:08:50

Upping the 25 gifted subs to 30 gifted subs for 3rd Bert.

https://www.twitch.tv/videos/905478506?t=03h10m18s "10 gift subs for pegwin." Updated his !pegwin command to reflect this. Talks more about how hard the contest would be in main lobbies.

This is the !pegwin command reply, btw:

"Special pegwins appear in tundra run, perfect match, and fall ball. The goal is to qualify in each while holding Bert! We are using custom lobbies to get Danger's the special magic dragon skin! If Dangers gets all three Berts, he will gift 25 subs! You can read more about it here; https://twitter.com/FallGuysGame/status/1358388574123606019?s=20"

https://www.twitch.tv/videos/905478506?t=04h12m07s - Tundra Run "win" This is the most egregious one, in my opinion, since it not only requires his private lobby to refrain from attacking him (and refrain from qualifying before him, preventing potential elimination), but it relies on them to do most of the work for him. First, he doesn't realize there is a Bert and continues on in the episode until they tell him to come back. Someone then delivers the Bert to him. Then he almost drops Bert off the side, but is saved by another player's quick reaction, who once again delivers Bert back to him.

Though I think the win was unfair, I'm not putting this out there to get anything taken away from the streamer or his viewers. It's not his fault that Fall Guys created the contest in a way that allowed for that kind of unfair advantage to be exploited, and I don't think he should be punished for it, because that helps no one. He believed it was achievable that way and very likely would have spent the time doing it differently had he known otherwise. And due to the nature of the contest, he may have still had an advantage in regular lobbies if friendly viewers from his stream sniped him, albeit not nearly as strong.

An additional note: Abridged qualifying clips are posted on his Twitter, so he's not hiding it and has stated that he will relinquish the costume if it's deemed against the rules. (Someone did inform him during stream about the above Fall Guys tweet referring to abuse of custom lobbies).

Again, I don't think him being punished for a loophole that was brought to the Fall Guys media team's attention and not addressed appropriately will solve anything. And I'm not here to take away anyone's happiness or fun, but to make sure that fun is tangible in a more equitable manner for others.

Fall Guys continuously puts all their efforts into boosting the streamers (some of which barely play the game anymore), while simultaneously neglecting their player base. This costume should either be made a crown achievement, or be made available to everyone at this point, (especially given the amount of hours so many put into both unbalanced contests).

Oh fun extra: The streamer who won the dragon in the first contest, sabotaging other players chances at it in this one:

https://www.twitch.tv/videos/905450349?t=04h55m34s

https://www.twitch.tv/videos/905450349?t=07h37m00s

I hope Mediatonic gives a sincere response and considers the community that has been there from the beginning.

*Note: In regards to Mediatonic saying they want "to keep the costume rare", that exposes another issue with this contest. This costume was shown in much of the Season 2 promotional material leading up to it, making it appear as if it would NOT be a rare or exclusive item. Further, the DLC costumes were presented along with the in-game costumes, creating additional potentially deceptive confusion regarding the upcoming season.

External link →
about 4 years ago - /u/OliverAge24Artist - Direct link

Here's the limitations that we were trying to work-around:

- We only are able to give around 100 costumes out because it is a manual process and takes a bunch of time for support to gift them out.

- We only wanted around 100 entries so that it wasn't too much work to go through and validate them

- We have no coding resources to add/modify/change the game in order to run the contest

- It needs to be something that is possible to record yourself doing

If you can think of other competitions that fit these requirements, please let us know, it's harder than it sounds.

Yes it was a very hard (almost impossible challenge) but that was the point. We made it easier when we realised JUST how hard it was, but if we'd made it too easy to start with, we couldn't have made it harder half way through.

Imagine if 4,000 people would have entered. It would have taken us weeks to get through all the entries and then to gift out all of the costumes.

We'd LOVE to do in-game costumes too, or many of the things people suggest, but there are restraints that we're trying to work around.

We were sad to see someone using custom lobbies to exploit this so we've brought a rule in for future competitions - no custom lobbies. We should have said that to begin with, but we didn't think streamers would try and do that.

We also reached out to the streamer you've linked and said that they can't trade in-game items for subscriptions in future.

Please can you explain this a bit further:

" Fall Guys continuously puts all their efforts into boosting their streamers (some of which barely play the game anymore), while simultaneously neglecting their player base "

How are we neglecting our player base?

This isn't really linked to this contest, but since you have brought it up within your thread:

We send exclusives to streamers because they are doing us a massive favour by playing the game and promoting it to their audiences. It's marketing. All games do it. Other games will just straight up pay streamers. Some games give them a cut of sales from in-game purchases. We just give them costumes that have no real-money value.

Just thinking of some other big games - Cyberpunk, literally put streamers in the game as characters... Fortnite has creator codes so streamers can earn money playing the game and puts them in as characters. I struggle to think of a recent game that hasn't had some sort of program or initiative with influencers/streamers.

about 4 years ago - /u/OliverAge24Artist - Direct link

Originally posted by epictiger01

Everything here makes total sense, except for one thing.

“but we didn’t think streamers would try and do that.”

I’m pretty keen on using all my available resources, and I don’t know if it’s just me, but if I had access I’d try it out immediately. It’s the simplest, most straightforward way to beat the competition.

I just honestly really didn't think the streamers would feel invested in the competition enough to spend hours trying to beat it, especially when I've been so freely giving them costumes.

Obviously, I was mistaken. Lesson learned though and we've brought in rules for next time.

about 4 years ago - /u/OliverAge24Artist - Direct link

Originally posted by vanna_volga

You:

" How are we neglecting our player base? "

Also you:

" especially when I've been so freely giving them costumes."

And you wonder why the majority of your player base is fed up with how you guys handle these events?

I don't get the connection between me gifting out promotional costumes to streamers and us "neglecting our player base"

about 4 years ago - /u/OliverAge24Artist - Direct link

Originally posted by [deleted]

[deleted]

Giving costumes to streamers doesn't "harm" our player base.

Streamers do a lot of marketing for the game... Which brings in more players... Which benefits our player base.

If you genuinely want to learn more about it, you can search influencer marketing.

It's why streamers got special free PS5's and Xbox One's with engravings...

Did that push people away from buying the consoles? No.

about 4 years ago - /u/OliverAge24Artist - Direct link

Originally posted by Frosticious150

Dude just stop trying to justify the things you do with rewards for the game and accept the fact you have pissed a lot of people off with your excuses and bullshit pandering to streamers and people with clout.

Okay, I accept you feel this way.

about 4 years ago - /u/OliverAge24Artist - Direct link

Originally posted by [deleted]

[deleted]

It's different for games as a live service. Look at Fornite adding in influencer costumes for example.

about 4 years ago - /u/OliverAge24Artist - Direct link

Originally posted by MarMar46

True but some of the problems are technically very obvious dont you think? Like the obvious streamers exploiting private lobbies and perfect match bert is just very very very unlikely to make him survive.

We knew there was a possibility for streamers to exploit private lobbies, we just didn't think they would. That was a mistake.

We also knew it was very unlikely for Bert to survive Perfect Match, but it was supposed to be really difficult. We made it too difficult so we switched up the rules and extended it.

about 4 years ago - /u/SootGremlin- - Direct link

Originally posted by ihatebloopers

I'm pretty sure on the discord they said only 3 of the 118 submissions were actually done correctly so you shouldn't have to enter a raffle.

That was me! I'm checking through the submissions - I've checked the first 118 so far and only 4 made the 2/3 Pegwins that we need, but those are all from the first 23 hours of the competition. We had 330 responses in total, and I expect that a lot more in that last day will qualify.
My hope is that 100 people managed to do it correctly, so then we can give the costume to everyone who did, but currently it's hard to say.

about 4 years ago - /u/SootGremlin- - Direct link

Originally posted by Omniscient_Platypus

I think the 100 max winners raffle for the 2 levels completed is one of the worst parts of this, I managed to get tundra run and fall ball by myself by staying up all night and getting stupidly lucky, and there’s still a very good chance that I’ll get nothing for it anyway, still haven’t heard anything yet or whether they’ll tell you if you won or not.

I’d say everyone who managed to get it in 2 levels deserves the costume, there’s enough RNG involved without a massive lucky dip at the end. I get they want a costume to be rare but I can’t honestly see more than about 200 to 500 getting it at a very rough estimate, which would still be literally nothing compared to the entire player base.

That said it was a unique and interesting challenge, that gave even private lobbied streamers a run for their money, and I’d be lying if I said I didn’t enjoy playing it, even with perfect match being practically impossible, but it’ll definitely leave a sour taste in my mouth if I end up getting nothing for it.

Hi! Well done for getting Tundra Run and Fall Ball! It's me that is going through all the submissions, so I'll just explain the current status.
We had around 330 submissions total, and I've been through 118 so far and 4 of them have got 2/3. Those are all from the first 23 hours, before anyone knew that 2/3 would qualify, so I'd expect that far more of those last 200 submissions will have made it. I also believe anyone who did it absolutely deserves the costume, it's simply down to limitation of resources.
That said, if we do get slightly over 100 qualifying submissions, we will extend the amount slightly. I can't say how many I expect to have done it, your guess is as good as mine at this point, but I am really hoping that around 100 did it correctly so that everyone can get the costume.
Also, just to clarify - you won't know if you've got it until you just check your inventory. Unfortunately we don't have in-game messaging to let you know, and I didn't want to take personal details in the form. I'm hoping to get the checking of the submissions finished today or tomorrow, but it'll take a while to get all the costumes gifted to people so I can't give you an ETA on when to check your inventory, but I'm hoping by the end of the week.

about 4 years ago - /u/SootGremlin- - Direct link

Originally posted by KingBlackToof

I don't understand the stance of, "we didn't want to validate 1000's of entries.".
If there were 4000, couldn't they just choose 1 at random, validate it and repeat x100 (+ a few more that turned out to be disqualified on the random picks)?
No need to validate all 4000 first.

Hi! It's me that's going through the submissions and I really wish that was the case (and tbh I think that's how I thought it would be before I actually started looking through them). I spent yesterday going through 118 out of the 330 submissions and only 4 were correct. It seems we underestimated how many people would send in three uncut videos of them playing Tundra Run, Fall Ball and Perfect Match in which they either dropped Pegwin or didn't even see him; three failed attempts at one level; or one failed attempt at Tundra Run, a handwritten letter and a video of them emoting on Fortnite.

about 4 years ago - /u/SootGremlin- - Direct link

Originally posted by Dry-Tone-1500

It’s the false advertisement that made the players angry. They said they aren’t going to show us the rate costumes in their ads again. Let’s hope they keep their promise. Accessibility of the game, to many players, includes cosmetic items, and the community managers should be clear about how they can be obtained. Transparency is key to good communication.

Totally agree, it was a big mistake on our part including them in the Season 2 trailer that we've been doing everything we can to prevent from happening in the future.

All DLC costumes have a variant colour that won't be in the store. Since the Season 2 mess up, I think we've done pretty well at keeping them out of trailers. A lot of the time our gameplay trailer footage is taken in our playtests, at which point we usually don't know which costume out of the two colour options will be in the DLC. During the playtests, we have most costumes available to use so it's a little tricky to make sure 100% that they don't make it in, but so far I think we've done pretty well at keeping them out. We'll continue to do everything we can to prevent them from being in promotional material.

about 4 years ago - /u/OliverAge24Artist - Direct link

Originally posted by johnnysilverpaw

I’m not usually one to comment but holy cow, you’re right. If they want to make things right then they should take away the costume from streamers who exploited private lobbies. You know they’d take it away from us regular players without hesitating.

It baffles me how they don’t see how this angers people, it’s pretty clear.

It's our fault for not making it a rule, we've learned from it, and next time we'll have some more rules in place.

about 4 years ago - /u/OliverAge24Artist - Direct link

Originally posted by Nyteshade517

In the future streamers won't even enter these contests because all they have to do is message Oliver and he'll give them whatever they want. And "What harm does sending free stuff to streamers cause?" or whatever nonsense BS Oliver said before...I dunno, pretty much makes me not want to believe anything that person says about the game because in your company's own way you're paying them to say it.

It sounds like you have an issue with Influencer Marketing - I'm really sorry to say but this is SUPER common. It's actually more uncommon for a game to do no Influencer Marketing at all now. I don't want to argue the pros/cons of it since it's an industry-wide thing. Actually, it's not even the games industry. Every industry.

about 4 years ago - /u/SootGremlin- - Direct link

Originally posted by Omniscient_Platypus

Ah ok, thanks very much for the info

Finally got through all the submissions yesterday and the costumes were sent out this morning. Out of 329 submissions, 46 people qualified to get one (of which 3 people got 3/3, and 43 people got 2/3) so well done if you did! It'll be in your inventory now if you did it.