Original Post — Direct link

Mentorship is gained the same way as Squad Leadership ribbons except only for BR30 or less toons, which is fine, but the issue with it now is that new players usually aren't amazingly squad-focused; even if you can herd all 11 of them into one base they aren't going to get a ton of squad EXP ticks, which makes the gain rate slow. On top of that is the fact that there aren't a ton of new players in Planetside, so we're on three layers of "if" now - if a lot of new players join the squad, if they go to the waypoint, if they help each other out. On top of that, I managed to get to about Mentor Rank 10 last night (though I assume some people could do much better), and it's reset straight back to 1 a little more than 12 hours later. Even if it's, say, 1 point per 2 hours, taking one day off of mentoring to actually enjoy the game instead of micromanage 11 clueless new players that don't even understand how to Redeploy could set you back three or four days worth of progress. Remember that you have to reach 200 Mentor score just to talk in the /new channel, which is probably the only part of the Mentor system that might improve the NPE at all. I get that it's supposed to be gated, but the current state just seems like it won't get used at all, and there might be one or two saints with no job and infinite patience that can stick a Silver rating. God help them if the decay scales.

(Also, the patch notes seem to lie: the Directive states that ribbons are for Squad EXP ticks, the patch notes say that it's for ranking up which is what Drill Sergeant currently does, not Mentorship.)

External link →
over 5 years ago - /u/Wrel - Direct link

Definitely going to be some adjustments in the next update. The gain is too low and the decay is somewhat aggressive. We'll be moving in the balance a bit on either side.

I haven't seen any trolling or inappropriate use of the channel so far, which has been nice, but usage is low, as you'd expect. It only takes one person to ask a question before a handful of people jump in and start answering, which in turn makes more people comfortable asking questions there, but these spurts of activity are few and far between.

As far as the barriers to entry go, as we mentioned in the patch notes, we'll be flagging trustworthy community members with permissions to answer questions, regardless of Mentor Rating, in the future. Outside of that, we'd be hesitant to drop the barriers too much right out the gate.

Would rather this feature cultivates the right community over time, even if the growth is slow.