Original Post — Direct link

https://preview.redd.it/xmb1akymxoc71.jpg?width=577&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ec6083a940d004eaff00040af4e99a9de5949e74

It should go without saying, but this post will contain a *lot* of spoilers for those who haven't played a large amount of the game. You have been warned.

  1. Xau-Tak survived the last Great Revision. The only other 2 known entities to pull off this feat are the Dragonkin and the Elder Gods themselves.
  2. Xau-Tak 'killed' an Elder God. While Mah survived, it is heavily suggested that Xau-Tak is personally responsible for attempting to kill her, and leaving her in her lesser, deformed state.
  3. Xau-Tak is associated with cold, black stone. Some of his followers (cave horrors) wear masks made from this stone, and the Shard of Erebus - described as central and 'key' to the Elder God Wars, is seemingly made from this same stone.
  4. Xau-Tak has cured dragonkin of their curse. The curse was inflicted by the Elder Gods, and lesser gods have demonstrated a total inability to influence it. Only Kerapac, a dragonkin himself, has demonstrated any ability to fight it, but his proposed 'cure' is only temporary, and utilizes the player (who, as world guardian, bears shadow anima in them).
  5. Speaking of... Xau-Tak is associated with shadow anima! Shadow Anima is always described as being 'something else', or 'from somewhere else'. Zaros describes a 'supposed' sixth Elder God as being 'not of form, but 'something else' during The Light Within. He uses the exact same phrasing to describe Raksha, a colossus imbued with shadow anima, and himself enters the Monolith (into a realm of shadow anima) during the end of the Battle for the Monolith... presumably to search for this sixth Elder.
  6. Xau-Tak has successfully violated the Edicts of Guthix. He directly attacks the player during Pieces of Hate - which takes place before Guthix's death. The only other known violations of the Edicts were perpetrated by Seren, Guthix, and Zaros - the first two choosing to slumber, and the third being non-present at the time of the Edicts (and thus, either not beholden to them, or more likely... unaware of them at all, and broken by accident). Likewise, the Elder Gods also violated them - but unintentionally, as they'd been slumbering at the time by coincidence. If they hadn't - who knows? Were the Elders beholden to the Edicts of a lesser god? Highly unlikely...
  7. Xau-Tak references time when describing him/her... or perhaps more aptly... itself. During a flashback, Xau-Tak possesses a man, turns to the player, and states: "Do you really think you can save them, Player? You can't. The spiral of time leads only to the gaping maw of eternity. And this is Xau-Tak.". This would suggest not only that Xau-Tak can peer forward in time (temporal phenomena is usually associated with Elder Gods), but that Xau-Tak even represents an aspect of time - just as the Elder Gods themselves do.
External link →
over 3 years ago - /u/darkhearted_raven - Direct link

Originally posted by swordblazer8

  1. 'everything in Erebus as far as we know survived?', the 'as far as we know' means this answer is grasping for straws. In truth, we don't know what Erebus is, and we don't know whether it comes from before, or after the last revision. I of course cannot claim that he, the Elder Gods, and the Dragonkin are the *only* beings that survived, and that's not what I say. I do include the words 'that we know of'. Any other survivors haven't been explicitly confirmed, and I am working on what is known, not what is unknown
  2. Directly from the Wiki: The Great Revision

Xau-Tak is apparently an ancient entity as old as the universe and the Elder Gods themselves. Sometime around The Great Revision that destroyed the previous cycle of the universe, Xau-Tak was somehow able to corrupt Mah's egg, causing her to be born malformed and resulted in only four Elder Gods being active at its start. As such, no... this is not a stretch, this is confirmed lore.

  1. The icon for the shard of Erebus is, yes, a different color - but only slightly. It's likely that this is simply because making it pure black would make it impossible to give the item detail. Compromises have to be made. What is known is that Xau-Tak is connected to shadow anima, as is the shard. I use the black mask as an example of other areas where this same connection has been drawn. I cannot comment on the inner workings of Erebus - as that is unknown territory. My evidence is based on what is known, not what is unknown.

  2. Destroying the stone was not a 'cure' from the curse - as demonstrated by Jas's continued control of the dragonkin against their will. It was merely a removal of the objective of the curse. The temporary cure I refer to is the cure Kerapac and the player use on Strisath in the quest One of a Kind wherein the World Guardian siphons wisps into him. They are very clear that the effect of this 'cure' will wear off.

  3. If Xau-Tak has connections to Erebus (which you agree with here), and Xau-Tak is connected to shadow anima (which you've also agreed with), then the shard of Erebus (which is connected to shadow anima) is thereby connected to Xau-Tak. Agreeing with me on this point only clarifies that I was, in fact, correct on point 3, regardless of which color Jagex happened to choose for the sprite.

  4. I am not sure if you are referring to Xau-Tak or Zaros with this rebuttal. Regardless of which... yes, both violated the edicts. From the wiki: "As the adventurer prepared to confront Rabid Jack, they encountered a mysterious kitten several times, seemingly only visible to them, whose dialogue and examine alluded to Xau-Tak's threats. During the fight against Rabid Jack, a giant black hand, supposedly Xau-Tak's, attacked the adventurer, thus indicating that Xau-Tak breached the Edicts of Guthix before the Assassination of Guthix." and "during the quest The Temple at Senntisten, one helps Azzanadra restore the Altar of Zaros in the Digsite Dungeon, the site of an ancient Zarosian city. Azzanadra then succeeds in contacting Zaros, who apparently inhabits a distant plane. Although Zaros does not come to Gielinor's plane at this time, some of his power is manifested on Gielinor, including damaging a statue of Zamorak at the Chaos Temple. This manifestation was theorised to have violated the Edicts of Guthix."

  5. This is also an interesting interpretation, however I do believe there may be some validity to it in the sense that Xau-Tak as an entity is likely to be portrayed as more powerful than the 4 remaining Elder Gods upon his arrival - sort of as the 'Nex' or 'Telos' extra boss of the EGWD, if I'm right. If that is the case, both my, and your interpretations are equally correct. They are not mutually exclusive ideas.

Not confirming or denying anything, but a reminder that the wiki is far from infallible and often has player theories or opinions worked into it under the guise of "fact". On more than a few occasions I've had references of my own work stated as being based on something I have never seen before (I had one reference to the soul abomination Gielinor as "confirmed" being based off a character from an anime I had never seen for example).

So be careful not to assume "it's on the wiki" is the same as canon. If you can't find specific wording to it in game, assume it's just a theory. ;)

over 3 years ago - /u/darkhearted_raven - Direct link

Originally posted by reachedsoftware

Unfortunately I’m not sure if Mod Jack was being completely serious when he said his tier was √-1, but the fact that they’re even joking about that means Xau-Tak certainly isn’t a normal god by any means.

It was Mod Wilson who made that comment and no he wasn't being entirely serious. ;)

over 3 years ago - /u/darkhearted_raven - Direct link

Originally posted by Brynxical

Can you hint when we'll get more xau-tak lore in-game? Pretty please.

No, I can't. ;)