Idiot here, is there any major reason players can’t have a choice? I think that your point about the entire map pool being overwhelming to new players is completely valid, but removing the option for any public matchmaking on those maps seems cruel. There are a lot of people who want to play the inactive map pool that don’t have 9 friends who play Valorant, much less 9 friends that can all play at the same time just so we can play on a different map.
A lot of the maps currently in the inactive pool are really fun, and as more maps are released, eventually a majority of the maps will be in the inactive pool. If this is the long term solution, there would be no way for a majority of players to actually play a majority of the game.
My idea would be a box that is checked by default every time you launch the game, put on the UI next to the queue button that says “Competitive Map Pool Only”. Have it there for every game mode (INCLUDING Unrated) that isn’t Comp or a game mode like TDM that doesn’t use the standard map pool. I’m sure it’s not nearly that simple, but it’s a compromise that satisfies all of your reasonings for taking the maps out of every game mode. The box being checked by default makes sure new players don’t get overwhelmed by accident, but allows players to opt in to the rest of the map pool if they choose.
I’m sure there are reasons that can’t be done, but as a fan of all of the maps currently in the inactive pool, it would be nice to be able to play them without having to get 9 friends on at the same time