Me too, random gets boring and your influence on outcome is smaller.
Some keep asking for skill-based mode — here it is, yes, very roughly, but still it really feels when you cross league boundaries that general difficulty jumps dramatically. That's why sometimes you keep bouncing between rank 11 and 10 — you're adjusting to difficulty. Premier league is hell (in a good way, i like challenge).
Now don't complain if in roughly skill-based mode your winrate gets closer to 50%, that's the point — you're on your skill level so to win you need to play to the fullest, use all your knowledge and skills to outsmart the enemy. to work together with your team as much as possible. You gotta sweat, cry and bleed. Now say — do you really want to always play like that? Don't you enjoy easy victories sometimes? That's the point of random PvP mode — it's random, you get varying difficulty and tier distribution.
Don't grind Ranked mode if you don't enjoy it. Get as far as you can, take a break, try again, if you feel it's your ceiling for now — that's fine. Maybe your ship does not fit well enough for current season, maybe you're not using it appropriately for that mode. If it's not fun learning and adapting and coming up with general tactics — no one forces you.