I have played 25 battles in Indomitable and I will tell you as someone that is a DD main but supposedly "above average" looking at WoWs Numbers in a CV, I find her to be a pretty fun. I have watched almost every single review but am always leery or careful of taking reviews or ideas of a specific class or ship type from people that A: Don't do particularly well in a ship type or specific ship or B: Haven't even played them.
As someone that started playing CV's in earnest after the rework and someone that also plays CV's a bit unconventionally compared to most the population, (I use them as support units more than anything) I find Indomitable to be a GREAT ship. I actually enjoy playing her more than Enterprise or any other Tier VIII CV. And that is even when I am uptiered. But that's just my 2 cents It definitely has a bit of a different play style than most however.
Mahalo,
-Hapa