[2020] What a descriptive wiki

And your best serves the community at large, thank you for being an editor!

considering the popularity and playerbase the wiki is really bad compared to even small games like rimworld or wazhack

With over 70k articles, the GW2 wiki is very well maintained considering the size (and age) of the game it documents. While I do not know the 2 wikis you indicate, they're small (the first has 15k article but it's only been there for 5 years compared to the 11 years of the GW2 wiki) and seem to correspond to small games. It's often easier to document something that has a limited amount of content.

There isn't a good benchmark of how good a wiki is but having helped its community for now more than 6 years, I believe that it's a AAA wiki for its content and it ranks pretty high in a few categories as you can see here (unfortunately they don't list articles, only pages): https://wikiapiary.com/wiki/Special:RunQuery/Website_by_Tag?Website_by_Tag%5BTag%5D=game&wpRunQuery=true

I'm pretty sure that the community of wiki editors would welcome your comments and ideas directly on the respective pages (in fact we've build a "Leave article feedback" feature exactly for that, see the corresponding tab).