Hahaha.
I don’t know what the actual design philosophy is, but I figured that weapons are not meant to be straight upgrades to others, and something like the Peacemaker is meant to be a reliable, neutral option for a sidearm, but not something that is outclassed totally by unlocks.
Using the redeemer on Semi-auto does make it feel like a superior version of the Peacemaker, as far as I’ve been able to tell. But I know the visible in-game stats are likely not the only factors at play and there could be hidden values and characteristics. My best guess is that the Peacemaker at least has better accuracy and damage falloff characteristics compared to the Redeemer.
Anyway, no game I know of has gotten balance right on the first try. I’m thrilled for changes so I’m gonna contain my excitement as best as I can. Thanks for the reply.