devtrackers.gg
5 months
ago -
Play New World
-
Direct link
Transcript (by Youtube)
| 0s | like the uh the skeleton archers when |
|---|---|
| 2s | they like Duck and you always like shoot |
| 3s | right over them and stuff well yeah and |
| 5s | it it totally plays into our combat |
| 7s | right like we have head shots uh they do |
| 9s | bonus damage there's certain abilities |
| 10s | where if you shoot in the legs you get a |
| 12s | slow like so we take advantage of all |
| 14s | this sort of uh cool stuff yeah we could |
| 16s | totally optimize by just becoming tap |
| 18s | Target right |
| 19s | no let's go to the next |
| 23s | [Applause] |
| 26s | question welcome to forge an ET turna |
| 29s | where we talk about all things new world |
| 31s | today we have a very special episode we |
| 33s | are joined by four senior Engineers on |
| 36s | the team this is the brains of the |
| 38s | operation this is what makes stuff |
| 39s | actually happen uh so uh we're going to |
| 43s | talk a little bit about what sort of |
| 44s | technical problems we've seen and like |
| 46s | what we're doing to work on them and a |
| 48s | little bit on the future of our Tech uh |
| 50s | but before I do that let me just quickly |
| 51s | introduce all the Geniuses here so we |
| 53s | have uh Scott geyser uh we have Julian |
| 57s | we have Kevin and Ed uh are one |
| 60s | wonderful senior |
| 61s | Engineers uh so let's start off with a |
| 64s | question something I see a lot like hey |
| 66s | I play a lot of opr or ecrs and you know |
| 70s | my my performance isn't really good I'm |
| 72s | I'm feeling laggy I get stutters uh |
| 74s | let's first talk about like what is that |
| 76s | actually from a technical perspective |
| 78s | like what are people seeing what are the |
| 79s | causes of that type of thing uh yeah so |
| 83s | um there's a there's quite a few things |
| 85s | that can happen when you're experiencing |
| 88s | um latency or or you know sometimes you |
| 91s | might see rubber banding um but the |
| 95s | basics of it is we send inputs up to the |
| 97s | server and the server needs to verify |
| 100s | those inputs uh with physics and then |
| 102s | come back down to your |
| 104s | machine and when you start to experience |
| 107s | that um that step of the pipeline on the |
| 111s | server um could take longer and so |
| 115s | typically like if you have a debug |
| 117s | console open you can see your rtt and |
| 120s | and once that rtt starts extending beond |
| 123s | 200 milliseconds um you may start |
| 126s | experiencing issues like that and that |
| 129s | can start to happen um specifically in |
| 132s | combat because um we're spawning a ton |
| 135s | of projectiles for one um typically in |
| 137s | combat of around 100 people uh we see |
| 141s | around 6,000 projectiles spells being |
| 144s | cast per minute and that can be an |
| 146s | expensive operation for the server so um |
| 150s | some of that time that was originally |
| 152s | dedicated to kind of making sure your |
| 154s | player updates is going to start to |
| 155s | distribute um amongst those |
| 158s | spells um another thing that can happen |
| 160s | is um we have sort of like um whenever |
| 164s | you're in like a close density with a |
| 166s | lot of people um we're trying to send |
| 170s | data uh to the um players that you see |
| 173s | and they're trying to send uh data to |
| 175s | you so you can see their positional |
| 176s | updates and a bunch of other things like |
| 179s | animation and stuff like that |
| 181s | and that problem um becomes basically |
| 184s | quadratic um once uh um once the density |
| 189s | of the number of players starts to |
| 190s | become too much |
| 193s | and so that's like another place where |
| 195s | the CPU on the server which is you know |
| 197s | sort of trying to update your inputs can |
| 200s | go and when those two things start to |
| 203s | happen um we start to see um basically |
| 206s | your rtt go up because we don't have |
| 208s | enough um CPU to handle the |
| 211s | density and so like the the creation of |
| 214s | all those new entities like every |
| 215s | projectile and stuff is like an |
| 217s | expensive operation itself right so the |
| 219s | fact that projectiles are shortlived and |
| 220s | created and then destroyed and then a |
| 222s | new one's created like that's expensive |
| 224s | and then like you were talking about |
| 225s | it's not just the players but also those |
| 227s | projectiles and every other Ai and opr |
| 229s | wherever you happen to be maybe it's an |
| 231s | influence tower all those things are |
| 232s | also updating down to every single |
| 234s | player yeah uh in in that area too and |
| 237s | wouldn't it be fair to say like I think |
| 239s | we do a lot more in terms of combat and |
| 242s | gameplay on the server than a lot of |
| 243s | games right so that stresses the systems |
| 245s | a little bit yeah I mean like every |
| 247s | basically Arrow every bullet now is an |
| 250s | actual um physical thing in the world |
| 252s | that actually moves through the space |
| 254s | and as it's moving through the space |
| 256s | it's trying to figure out what it's |
| 258s | colliding with and um you know we don't |
| 261s | use raycast um for like uh hit scan |
| 263s | anymore um so there's just a lot of um |
| 267s | basically things moving through space in |
| 269s | our game um |
| 271s | and yeah it can be computationally |
| 273s | expensive the character is also |
| 274s | represented by sorry the character is |
| 277s | also represented by physics uh bounds |
| 279s | all over their body uh so that we can |
| 281s | distinguish a head shot or an arm shot |
| 283s | or a leg shot and you can also duck or |
| 286s | go prone under these things so as you're |
| 288s | moving through the world it's moving |
| 290s | these representation with you um and |
| 292s | that ends up being more expensive than |
| 294s | than a usual MMO how they handle it like |
| 297s | the uh the skeleton archers when they |
| 298s | like Duck and you always like shoot |
| 299s | right over |
| 301s | well yeah and it it totally plays into |
| 302s | our combat right like we have head shots |
| 304s | they do bonus damage there's certain |
| 306s | abilities where if you shoot in the legs |
| 307s | you get a slow like so we take advantage |
| 309s | of all this sort of uh cool stuff yeah |
| 312s | we could totally optimize by just |
| 313s | becoming tap Target right no no let's go |
| 316s | to the next question what is scale |
| 319s | testing scale testing yeah what is it so |
| 321s | we try to we try to emulate what's going |
| 323s | to happen in the game using butts so |
| 325s | basically AIS uh and they do very simple |
| 329s | task uh that we Define that we write uh |
| 332s | for example in combat uh the most common |
| 334s | one is like having them fight and run |
| 337s | around and see uh you know look at some |
| 340s | dashboards that we create as well uh and |
| 343s | see you know uh the metrics see they |
| 344s | align with what we expect um the |
| 347s | beginning of that process is like we |
| 350s | always write write like technical |
| 352s | documents and we explain how the feature |
| 354s | is going to work how much it's going to |
| 355s | cost the various different costs we have |
| 357s | and then we verify using the scale test |
| 360s | um running scale test and so we use bus |
| 362s | for that uh different like different |
| 364s | ways all the features are kind of |
| 366s | different so require different uh |
| 368s | testing um but in the end that's that's |
| 371s | what we're doing we're trying to emulate |
| 372s | what's going to happen in the game um as |
| 374s | best as we can because you know it's an |
| 376s | open world game so everything is kind of |
| 379s | happening sometimes differently than we |
| 380s | expect so we we we do our best in that |
| 384s | that are you yeah I think like the hard |
| 387s | part in creating those scale tests is |
| 390s | making it um behave in a way that's like |
| 393s | what players are doing like players are |
| 396s | always surprising us with what they're |
| 398s | doing and like we'll think we've got |
| 401s | like a good scale test and then we'll |
| 402s | see in live like performance starting to |
| 405s | to drop and we go in and we see what |
| 407s | they're doing and it's just like we |
| 409s | didn't think they were going to do that |
| 410s | and they did it and so now we have to re |
| 412s | you know write our scale test to kind of |
| 415s | help mimic that worst case yeah a good |
| 418s | example is like which one it's hard for |
| 420s | me to just evaluate is like World buses |
| 423s | cuz you don't know how many players are |
| 424s | going to show up so you try to aim for |
| 426s | like a certain number of |
| 427s | players but that could go over that |
| 430s | number very easily so you always tend to |
| 433s | aim for the worst case scenario but even |
| 435s | that is kind of hard to gauge right can |
| 437s | be different than what you're going to |
| 438s | get in the game in the end so it's very |
| 440s | hard and um so like when we're talking |
| 443s | about like that the targeted number of |
| 444s | players for like a particular activity |
| 446s | right um we're we we that's part partly |
| 450s | the difficulty of the the world boss and |
| 452s | all that that's sort of like the floor |
| 454s | of how many players we expect like are |
| 455s | necessary to to complete that type of |
| 457s | content but then like in the open world |
| 459s | the ceiling is basically you know until |
| 462s | the server explodes right so we have to |
| 465s | have mitigations for that so that you |
| 467s | know other people playing in a |
| 469s | completely different part of the world |
| 470s | but like sort of on that same Hub like |
| 473s | don't have a bad experience because |
| 475s | people are like crammed together |
| 476s | shoulder-to-shoulder fighting a world |
| 477s | boss like in a different place and so |
| 480s | you know for the influence races for |
| 482s | example like that feature had to take |
| 485s | some of the tech we used for the uh our |
| 487s | Fort capture uh areas because we want |
| 490s | PVP especially to be responsive um and |
| 494s | so that sort of has a lower kind of |
| 497s | ceiling of how many players we want to |
| 499s | be in that area that we feel like still |
| 501s | gives us like a good experience even |
| 503s | even like at maximum capacity um and |
| 507s | then for PVP also because we're you know |
| 510s | a faction vaction vaction game um you |
| 513s | know it wouldn't be fair for one faction |
| 514s | just you know take up all the capacity |
| 516s | so for towers and and Forts and stuff |
| 519s | you know that feature broke it down even |
| 520s | further by having limits for each |
| 523s | faction and how many of those flag |
| 524s | people can be in there um but in other |
| 528s | just open parts of the world we have |
| 530s | higher higher capacity and different |
| 532s | mechanisms of either you know if |
| 534s | something gets really dense maybe we'll |
| 535s | teleport some of the people away um or |
| 538s | you'll see like a physical barrier you |
| 539s | just won't be able to get into an area |
| 541s | like a long time ago when we had Wars |
| 543s | that weren't instanced right you'd be |
| 545s | running towards or like kind of like |
| 546s | near the fort and you just run into that |
| 548s | wall um and you wouldn't know what's |
| 550s | going on oh it must be a war going on |
| 552s | over there um but now like you know we |
| 554s | take that out of the open world and and |
| 555s | so that gives that area back to the |
| 558s | players yeah one of the things that we |
| 560s | did improve for the expansion is um |
| 563s | influence races um like Scott was saying |
| 566s | we we did cap that at around I think 100 |
| 568s | 150 um but other areas in the game we |
| 571s | were able to increase the number of |
| 573s | players we could get into areas uh the |
| 575s | density of basically the number of |
| 578s | players um and so what that means is |
| 581s | like you know you you hopefully won't be |
| 583s | seeing that that kind of wall anymore um |
| 586s | hopefully we did a good enough job where |
| 587s | that doesn't happen anymore |
| 590s | but cool well you've talked about a |
| 592s | couple things we've done already we've |
| 593s | instanced War which has sort of helped |
| 595s | uh we've done some things to increase |
| 596s | density what else have we done already |
| 598s | like sort of in the last year what else |
| 600s | is is on top of mine to continue to |
| 602s | improve in |
| 605s | performance well so one of the most |
| 607s | expensive parts of of the game is the |
| 609s | player simulation uh because the player |
| 612s | has so many things that they can do so |
| 614s | many abilities they can cast spells or |
| 617s | shoot weapons or interact with different |
| 619s | things in the environment like Gathering |
| 620s | things so um in order to help improve on |
| 625s | that we're we're working on lots of |
| 626s | optimizations on on the player and |
| 629s | trying to improve its memory footprint |
| 630s | as well as its uh the amount of time it |
| 633s | takes for it to to do all these |
| 634s | abilities uh and so this is a |
| 636s | significant amount of work that we've |
| 637s | been working that we've been doing this |
| 639s | this past year and uh it's it's getting |
| 642s | close to being done we're we're working |
| 644s | on bugs with it now and uh it's it's |
| 647s | making a a it's showing up some pretty |
| 649s | good |
| 650s | results yeah and now that we're at the |
| 652s | point sort of that like we feel we're |
| 655s | we've got you know we were in that phase |
| 656s | where we're cramming features in and |
| 657s | trying to get up to you know parody and |
| 659s | or you know with other games in the the |
| 661s | industry and things like that and now I |
| 663s | feel like we're we're taking a step back |
| 665s | and trying to really optimize things and |
| 667s | and get things to run smoother and |
| 668s | quicker um and more performant just to |
| 671s | both to increase the experience for |
| 673s | players but also it gives us some wiggle |
| 675s | room then to add more stuff you know in |
| 677s | the future yeah I mean I think that's |
| 679s | important for people to realize right |
| 680s | like an engineer can only do X things at |
| 683s | once right and so we've got to make |
| 684s | decisions between should we make a |
| 686s | feature should we fix bugs should we |
| 688s | optimize uh and those are all decisions |
| 690s | we've had to make and I think like you |
| 691s | said a lot of the focus has been on |
| 693s | features and sort of getting up to a |
| 695s | point where we're happy and now we have |
| 696s | more time to start addressing bugs and |
| 701s | optimizations uh anything else on |
| 703s | performance you guys want to talk about |
| 705s | anything I |
| 707s | missed maybe we talk about the world |
| 709s | itself yeah okay I'm not I'm not a |
| 712s | specialist |
| 713s | though but I know I specialist on |
| 715s | everything I know we're trying to uh |
| 717s | title World specialist |
| 720s | I'm doomed here um we we also look at uh |
| 724s | uh the cost of rendering the world |
| 727s | overall uh and we know sometimes we in |
| 730s | some areas uh we can be over budget so |
| 733s | we look at reducing you know like |
| 735s | geometry and reducing drold and stuff |
| 737s | like that especially when on top of that |
| 739s | you spawn a world bus that's going to |
| 742s | bring uh the bus itself all the AIS plus |
| 745s | a bunch of players plus all sometimes it |
| 748s | spawns also like itions or you know like |
| 750s | props or stuff like that so you add more |
| 752s | geometry in there and so if you were |
| 754s | already over budget you're even more |
| 756s | over Bridget so the goal is TR to figure |
| 758s | out how we can make all the slices uh |
| 761s | cheaper um sometimes just as simple as |
| 765s | removing stuff you know uh to just |
| 767s | reduce overall the complexity of the |
| 769s | scene that you have to render um and |
| 771s | that's an ongoing |
| 773s | uh uh you know initiative that's going |
| 776s | to I think it's going to take time to |
| 778s | just go past the point where we are on |
| 781s | budget everywhere even if you spawn |
| 783s | something uh sometimes also like events |
| 785s | like winter events we we spawn entire |
| 787s | Village uh so it's a lot you know um or |
| 791s | The Summer Event is the same uh so yeah |
| 793s | that's that's also one initiative that |
| 795s | we're working on takes a lot of |
| 797s | time and as we mentioned before that |
| 799s | spawning stuff is expensive because we |
| 800s | have to replicate all the the |
| 802s | information for it down to the client |
| 804s | and then reproduce it as well as we can |
| 807s | um and and that's an area that we we a |
| 809s | lot on for the player as well to improve |
| 811s | the player spawning um which will also |
| 813s | affect AI as well um since AI does |
| 816s | sometimes there's delays on on how |
| 818s | quickly they |
| 820s | spawn yeah I was just going to say |
| 823s | that um you |
| 826s | know what Julian was saying um like a |
| 829s | lot of the time it's trying to figure |
| 830s | out where in the world um our |
| 833s | performance is is going bad and we've |
| 835s | done a lot lately to um include a lot |
| 838s | more metrics |
| 839s | um into our um basically Telemetry |
| 843s | reporting um so now we can see um like |
| 846s | areas in the game that are over budget |
| 848s | with um draw calls or materials and on |
| 852s | top of that like we're doing a lot more |
| 854s | on the server as well where we can see |
| 856s | um where things are becoming less |
| 858s | performant and we can really drill into |
| 860s | areas and and see why and what in our |
| 863s | pipeline is sort of taking the most time |
| 865s | and I think you know finding the issues |
| 869s | is is sort of like half the battle and |
| 871s | then like Distributing it out to people |
| 874s | to fix is the other half and um I think |
| 877s | we've made a lot of progress in the last |
| 878s | year of like creating better systems to |
| 881s | find the |
| 883s | issues awesome uh one other thing I |
| 886s | wanted to touch on so we talked a little |
| 887s | bit about performance another technical |
| 889s | thing people sometimes complain about |
| 891s | are bugs I think you know for instance |
| 893s | with the season 3 release we had a |
| 895s | couple issues with the season pass and |
| 897s | Quest what if anything are we doing to |
| 899s | sort of get better at sort of that and |
| 901s | how do how does things like that |
| 903s | happen I guess I can take the quest not |
| 905s | the quest |
| 907s | actually uh so for the season pass we |
| 909s | had we what happened not going too much |
| 912s | into details but a we did like some |
| 915s | refactoring cut refactoring and um that |
| 919s | that actually broke the way we were |
| 921s | saving all the data um uh and so at some |
| 925s | point we had issues where our world |
| 927s | would not save progression anymore |
| 929s | um and it was actually to a point where |
| 932s | we had to recover from there so first |
| 933s | you have to fix the bug you have to find |
| 935s | what what the bug is took us some time |
| 938s | then you have to fix it when you have |
| 939s | the fix out you can go from into like |
| 941s | fixing mode into recovery mode which |
| 943s | like how do we get give players back |
| 946s | what they lost in this case like SE |
| 947s | season |
| 948s | XP um so at that point you really like |
| 951s | on Telemetry to kind of figure out |
| 953s | like how much season they last each of |
| 956s | the player right so we can give it back |
| 958s | in some case we also have players who |
| 959s | bought levels uh they paid for it didn't |
| 961s | get them on time or didn't get them at |
| 963s | all um so we always work on like trying |
| 966s | to extract all the data from our tretry |
| 969s | so we can um run what we call make Goods |
| 972s | where we give back to players what they |
| 973s | lost so it could be like as I said like |
| 976s | what you what you paid for or it could |
| 978s | be sayon XP so you you get back your XP |
| 981s | uh and you're back into where you should |
| 982s | be uh but also we had issues where |
| 984s | people could not claim anymore um so we |
| 987s | had to fix those issues as as well uh |
| 989s | and all of these are like kind of new |
| 991s | issues that we've never experienced so |
| 993s | it's kind of brand new situation for us |
| 995s | we've never been put into so we figure |
| 997s | out as we go right so and as fast as we |
| 999s | can because we we know players are very |
| 1001s | unhappy about |
| 1002s | it go for it Scott you you you had to |
| 1005s | fix like your share your good number of |
| 1007s | issues so go for it um yeah and so that |
| 1009s | sort of like speaks to especially within |
| 1011s | MMO how interconnected all these |
| 1013s | different systems are like a bug in the |
| 1015s | persistent system right and then also |
| 1018s | issues in interacting with like our |
| 1020s | entitlement service and all those things |
| 1022s | kind of combine only when there's like |
| 1024s | high load or you know like tons of |
| 1027s | players and it it kind of shows how |
| 1030s | tough it can be sometimes to recreate |
| 1032s | those exact situations before it goes |
| 1034s | out to uh real players um and uh on |
| 1039s | another note like what you were talking |
| 1041s | about with the make goods and all that |
| 1042s | that's something that we've been |
| 1042s | investing in you know since launch and |
| 1044s | slowly increasing our capacity to do |
| 1046s | that and do it more quickly and do it |
| 1048s | more accurately I remember at launch |
| 1050s | right we're like okay something's |
| 1051s | happening but we're not really sure how |
| 1053s | or why we just know that this thing is |
| 1055s | happening and we didn't have like ways |
| 1057s | to query our Telemetry and and see like |
| 1060s | okay EXA like this is what's happening |
| 1061s | and then this is the order of events and |
| 1063s | this is how we reproduce the issue or |
| 1064s | these are the players that are you know |
| 1067s | that were affected by this loss or are |
| 1069s | performing this exploit or something |
| 1070s | like that um and so you know like we're |
| 1073s | we just have a much better sense now of |
| 1076s | exactly what's going on in the game |
| 1077s | across all of our worlds |
| 1080s | and what explain what a red button is |
| 1082s | that's another new tool we've Have and |
| 1084s | Have unfortunately had to use every now |
| 1085s | and then the the red button is the word |
| 1087s | we use for uh like something's wrong |
| 1090s | turn it off shut it down um and yeah per |
| 1094s | feature and so you know we learned from |
| 1096s | our lessons like from launch and and |
| 1098s | moving forward uh and so we've as a |
| 1101s | standard practice you know we're much |
| 1102s | more granular in what we can shut off |
| 1104s | like before it was like you know shut |
| 1106s | the whole economy down right and now we |
| 1108s | can say okay shut off player-to-player |
| 1110s | trades or shut off you know certain |
| 1112s | items or certain abilities or you know |
| 1114s | we have we have a lot more control there |
| 1116s | so that if something happens hopefully |
| 1117s | we're not affecting everyone's player |
| 1119s | appearence yeah actually on this issue |
| 1121s | like the season pass we turned off |
| 1123s | buying the premium and buying levels |
| 1125s | because people would you know buy them |
| 1127s | and not receive them so uh when we |
| 1129s | figure out an issue like that we tend to |
| 1131s | you know uh turn it off as fast as we |
| 1133s | can so we can actually assist the the |
| 1135s | problem and not making a bigger problem |
| 1138s | right so it's always about mitigations |
| 1140s | and going back and figure out what |
| 1141s | happened and going from there to fixing |
| 1143s | the issue and then once the issue is |
| 1145s | fixed like okay give back to players |
| 1147s | what they lost and at that point we're |
| 1149s | done one more question I had is |
| 1151s | sometimes when I'm like in the middle of |
| 1152s | PVP I'll start an attack or an ability |
| 1154s | and like it'll either go backwards or my |
| 1157s | position will jump a little bit what |
| 1158s | what's going on there from a technical |
| 1160s | standpoint uh so it'll depend on what |
| 1162s | you see so if if you see the character |
| 1165s | their animation reset then you might |
| 1166s | have experienced a roll back there um if |
| 1169s | it's just their position moving then |
| 1170s | it's probably just the server correcting |
| 1172s | your position um because we have to |
| 1174s | balance uh how much we do on the client |
| 1177s | with how much we U validate on the |
| 1180s | server um and so in order to be to to |
| 1182s | have Fair combat for all the players um |
| 1185s | the server really needs to check on if |
| 1187s | you if you can attack or if you actually |
| 1189s | hit someone or if someone hit you while |
| 1191s | you were attacking um and then it it |
| 1193s | also takes time for the server to tell |
| 1195s | you these things um for you to send up |
| 1197s | your input to the server and then the |
| 1199s | server to correct it and send it back |
| 1200s | down to you uh so sometimes if there's a |
| 1203s | bit of a delay and the server is really |
| 1204s | busy there's lots of combat going on uh |
| 1207s | sometimes that uh that correction can be |
| 1209s | uh delayed a little bit so uh the longer |
| 1211s | it's delayed the more movement you'll |
| 1213s | see being corrected um the more |
| 1216s | animation the difference in your |
| 1217s | animation there might be um and so like |
| 1220s | one of the worst situations is if you're |
| 1222s | you're swinging to attack someone else |
| 1225s | um but then something kind of out off |
| 1227s | screen hit you um but that happened on |
| 1229s | the server before you actually attacked |
| 1231s | and so you'll see yourself go from the |
| 1233s | middle of an attack back to a |
| 1235s | reaction um and so it can be pretty |
| 1237s | jarring uh and we're there's actually |
| 1240s | part of the player optimizations we're |
| 1242s | working on are hopefully going to smooth |
| 1243s | that a little bit um but that uh that's |
| 1246s | kind of the like the real world physics |
| 1248s | we can't we can't uh there's nothing to |
| 1250s | get around the time it takes for |
| 1252s | communications to go to the server and |
| 1254s | back so it's just something that happens |
| 1256s | in massively multiplayer games |
| 1259s | and is that so when people say a desync |
| 1262s | that means that their animation changes |
| 1264s | generally then yeah so it's the server |
| 1266s | did something different um from what |
| 1268s | your local client is doing because your |
| 1270s | local client it doesn't have all the |
| 1271s | information from the other what the |
| 1273s | other players are doing um and uh so it |
| 1276s | might it might take a little bit of time |
| 1277s | for your your client to react so the |
| 1279s | server might just come down and say no |
| 1281s | you were you're supposed to be in this |
| 1283s | animation and you're supposed to be at |
| 1284s | this position and so then the client |
| 1286s | will move you there and and roll your |
| 1288s | back roll your animation back to that |
| 1291s | state awesome hey well thanks to |
| 1294s | everyone for joining us today I I love |
| 1297s | diving into this stuff I don't really |
| 1298s | understand all it so I trust these |
| 1302s | guys uh and uh I do have a community |
| 1305s | question for the day we'd love to hear |
| 1307s | sort of what are the technical issues |
| 1309s | you're experiencing the game let us know |
| 1311s | uh put it in the comments and and these |
| 1313s | guys will fix it as soon as they can SC |
| 1316s | fix |
| 1316s | it and uh as always thanks for joining |
| 1319s | us please like And subscribe and see you |
| 1321s | in a |
| 1330s | [Music] |
| 1331s | [Applause] |
| 1336s | [Music] |
| 1339s | turnament |