How to vote when you agree with the premise, but disagree with the implemintation?

Hey everyone,

Just curious how others handle this situation—I’ve run into a bit of a dilemma when voting in some of the recent in-game polls.

There are times when I really agree with the premise of a question—like I think the game should change in the general direction they’re suggesting—but I’m not happy with how it's being implemented or the specifics of the proposal. It’s frustrating, because I feel like the idea is better than the status quo, but not quite right yet.

So I end up stuck asking myself:

• Do I vote yes and hope that future feedback will refine it?
• Or do I vote no, even though I actually want some version of the idea in the game?

What also concerns me is the possibility that voting no might bury the idea altogether, and we won’t get a second chance at a better version. On the flip side, voting yes might push through a half-baked update that’s hard to undo.

I was thinking it might be helpful if the polling system had a feeback option for 'no' votes—something like:

“I agree with the premise, but not the current execution.”

"I disagree with both premise and execution"

Might be useful feedback for the devs to know if the concept of a poll didn't pass, or the proposed execution.

Curious how the rest of you approach this. What’s your logic when you’re torn like this? And do you think a more nuanced polling option would be beneficial?