almost 2 years ago - Ahskance - Direct link

Can you explain what you meant with this? How is Bearn considered an outlier?

almost 2 years ago - Ahskance - Direct link

The fighters are extremely tanky, but the pilots in those fighters only have a view range of 2km. If the plane itself is 2.1km from a Battleship with massive Air Detect, they do not see it.

So, you're saying the ability to place fighters directly over a high value target is oppressive because the fighters will require an inordinate amount of time to shoot down if the ship being hovered is unable to move?

almost 2 years ago - Ahskance - Direct link

Setting a Patrol Fighter to Patrol an area is not griefing a DD. It's using a consumable to stake a claim on a map position. Standard Fighters have very little health, but the Bearns Fighters are low visibility/high health which does make them uniquely capable for the task you are describing.

I don't think the expanded radius alters the actual flight pathing of the planes.

You may have missed this thread where a lot of topics were discussed: https://forum.worldofwarships.com/topic/255211-cvs-in-ranked/?do=findComment&comment=5756948

I can copy/paste my response on KotS, which was updated per the request of KotS organizers in the CC Program.

almost 2 years ago - Ahskance - Direct link

Did the picture I posted not appear for you? I can copy/paste the KotS section of the referenced post instead.

-

"The reasoning for CVs not being in Clan Battles is written above.

The reasoning for CVs not being in King of the Sea is because of a Player Vote. The KotS tournament was player-organized and previously included CVs. There was a podcast where an organizer described how after the Rework there were constant changes as CVs were being brought into line post-release and the competitive players believed CV to be too powerful to include in the tournament. The KotS organizers ran a poll and CVs were requested to be excluded. They made a decision that KotS would remain in the BB/CA/DD format, so that format remained.

WG did purchase King of the Sea but have not altered the rather successful format that existed when it was purchased."

-

As to the above referenced "Not being in Clan Battles", the response was:

"CVs alter the way Clan Battles are played on a fundamental level. Ship-choice is altered due to AA and Spotting constraints. Also, deployments are scouted so there is more of a strategy based on grind/attrition as opposed to novelty and/or surprise. As such, you can expect to see Seasons with CVs and Seasons without CVs because of how the gameplay is altered with the addition/subtraction of a Ship Type.

We have stated CVs will return to Clan Battles, but we've kept them out so players can have other experiences as we tried out the Unique-ship restriction which was very popular and we're going to be see what Superships are chosen and how they are used in the coming Clan Battle season."

-

My engagement with that thread resulted in some rather long replies. You can read them there: https://forum.worldofwarships.com/topic/255211-cvs-in-ranked/