Hi @ZeddBrew apologies for the late response.
I'm also sorry to hear that you are still experiencing this issue after disabling the Light-Fingered skill as well as all other skills.
Could you please provide a video that demonstrates this issue. In the video we would need to see the following:
- That you have the latest update installed. This can be seen on the main menu screen before loading your save.
- That you have disabled the 'Light-Fingered' skill.
- That you do not get a prompt to steal the key.
I would recommend uploading your video to a video sharing platform such as YouTube, you can then copy the URL link into this thread.
Can you also ensure that your latest save is uploaded to the cloud. If you are unsure how to do this there is a support article that you can check here.