[2022] Wait, we can't gather candy without being forced to do Nightmare? Bad Trick for Halloween.

Hey, excluding anyone wasn't our intention. We wanted it to be on Nightmare so it's not present in every game. You can also avoid it on Nightmare by using a custom difficulty preset.

The candy and jack o lanterns give 5 sanity each so you should be able to avoid any hunts until you need that ghost photo. You don't need to complete any objectives to get the trophy, as soon as you take that ghost photo it is complete.