Read moreWould it be better to meganerf Irelia and her support cards until the deck isn't competitively viable, but keep it technically possible to play it on a standard ranked ladder?
yes, absolutely this, for dedicated irelia players her current position of being "playable in ranked but on the weak side" is ABSOLUTELY preferable to "literally unplayable in standard ranked but maybe stronger in an unsupported format".
most of my favorite champions are in B and C tier and i will still be gutted the day i can't lose with terrible homebrews in ranked anymore.
was the idea of leaving champions intact and 'balancing through rotation' by hitting their support packages ever considered? would irelia be such a scary champion to design around if greenglade duo + sparring student weren't in standard?
i know there are lots of discussions happening behind the scenes but i've been surprised to see zero public consideration of this idea, which ...
yes, absolutely this, for dedicated irelia players her current position of being "playable in ranked but on the weak side" is ABSOLUTELY preferable to "literally unplayable in standard ranked but maybe stronger in an unsupported format".
Just to be clear, her current position hasn't been mega-nerfed. She's just been nerfed, but is still a potential consideration in the format. She is still sharply restricting design space for token decks.
She would have to be nerfed way, way more to make her truly irrelevant in the competitive metagame. That's the point of mega-nerfing, to make something so weak it might as well not exist when it comes to competitive balance; so that the card is no longer restricting design space.