What platform are you on?
You might want to try clearing Unity's (the game engine's) player prefs as well as Odd Realm's saved settings. Follow these steps below:
WINDOWS
1. Delete unity related settings (PlayerPrefs):
Open the Registry Editor:
Press Win + R, type regedit, and press Enter.
Navigate to:
HKEY_CURRENT_USER\Software\Unknown Origin Games\OddRealm
Right-click the folder for the game and choose Delete.
2. Delete Odd Realm Saves and Settings:
Navigate to the folder where Unity saves persistent data:
C:\users\you\appdata\locallow\Unknown Origin Games\OddRealm
Delete the entire folder to clear saved game data.
OSX
1. Delete unity related settings (PlayerPrefs):
Open Finder and go to:
~/Library/Preferences/Unknown Origin Games.OddRealm.plist
Delete the .plist file for the game.
2. Delete Odd Realm Saves and Settings:
Open Finder and go to:
~Library/Application Support/...
Read more