You're not going to rerun a pumpkin hat because reasons. That's the definition of FOMO. In games with a subscription, that has at least some basis in logic. Here, there isn't any. I get the no party hats or w/e. But this is a bit different.
It’s just some polygons shaped as a hat, not a $100 dollar board game on Kickstarter. We’ll give you a new pumpkin hat (not ruling out the old one reappears). If you have a better suggestion for giving people something small for being with us at a given point in time, let me know. We’ve previously had old hats at a higher price in the in-game store, but people had to buy them for each class. Now they’re claimable at game start, so you can’t miss them during the event - but it is just that: an event.