my bad for coming off ignorant;
But click intensity should not be the decider for XP rates, determining how the actual minigame plays out. You get Wintertodt that gives tremendous amounts of XP compared to other games, and that is nowhere near click intensive, the money is actually alright, as too are the rewards. But that skill offers nothing.
You can also argue the same for RC. You can kill almost anything in PvE and receive runes of all kinds. So it makes doing the skill useless in retrospect.
WT gives seeds & it gives logs, a tome which is useful especially late game for spells like fire surge. WT gives fletching XP & WC XP.
This minigame will provide nothing new to the game. And worst case scenario, because of the lack of buffed XP rates it will end up like Trouble Brewing. Nobody wants to touch it because it lacks purpose.