Gonna hijack this to mention, my main concern with generic animations, is that while they make it easier to give older pets overrides, they'll just be used in the future instead of proper animations for new pets? Like a new boss pet might come out and instead of taking the time to animate it properly, it will just have generic animations instead?
I think it needs to be carefully done on a case by case basis, some pets like penny, eddy, effy, the phoenix egglings, slayer co-op store pets etc would be fine with generic animations, but then a pet like the jad pet or cresbot would look really cool slamming the ground like the actual NPC's do.
As for the whole pet poll, I was pretty strongly against it for the reasons you mentioned, redoing the same content, rng, too many pets already. My favourite pet at the moment is perdita, because it's hard to get but also is guaranteed. The moment something is RNG based, people will get it quickly which devalues it for those who ar...