Definitely a controversial take, but the Waterfall Quest and Knight's Sword predate our current best practice for quest XP rewards, and from a balancing perspective, it would be preferable if their lamps (or quest accept) either had a suitable level requirement or awarded less XP.
They skip a massive chunk of the initial levels for their skills, and that's where you're learning how to level those skills and getting the most satisfying succession of rapid 'dings'.
On the other hand, the 'mastery knowledge', that there are techniques experienced players can use to accelerate their progress when making alts, is something some players enjoy, so it's a tricky thing to nerf.
In a 2017 TAPP project, I did an improvement project to the Knight's Sword that included converting its 12k Smithing XP reward to a lamp with a suitable level requirement. We ultimately removed the 28 Smithing requirement from the lamp a few months later due to the ongoing outcry.
On t...
Read more