Jagex_Stu

Thanks for being so nice about it. :)

Did you create your account before Monday 15th? If so, it'll have the old set of 5 basic challenges that include Basic Combat and Basic Prayer. (Even if you can't seem them on your challenge list, as we now display 3 challenges at a time.)

Eh, I wrote the fix for combat/prayer skillers in a modular way that could be easily applied to other basic challenges, so it's not a hassle on my end.

I'll ask my team on Monday if I can reopen it and apply the same condition to all basic challenges.

Means all basic challenges won't reward any XP any more, but it might be better for a truly new player to initially engage with the core loop of skills without modifiers anyway. :)

I see. I guess I could do the same thing to the new 9 basic challenges that I did to the old Basic Combat and Basic Prayer challenges, and give them all a chat option to skip them, and make them not reward XP when you claim them.

Does mean henceforth all new players won't get XP from basic challenges because of your One Skill At A Time Account. Are you okay to have that on your conscience? ;)

Or do you have the old set of 5 basic challenges from before weekly rewards were added? (Fishing, Woodcutting, Mining, Combat, Prayer). If so I could focus on just those 5, since new players no longer get them..

Hopefully the above fix in progress solves that for you, if the XP from the Basic Combat and Basic Prayer challenges are where the problem lie for you?

Or is there another basic challenge that's problematic for OSAAT?

Not currently, but Thursday evening I finished implementing a patch to bypass specific basic objectives that have been cause for concern, and remove their completion XP reward.

Fresh from the oven so needs to go through review, QA and release candidate testing, though.

To clarify, is it specifically the Basic Combat and/or Basic Prayer challenge you want to bypass?

And basic challenges don't expire, so unfortunately, no, waiting it out isn't currently an option.

(The post in this thread I intended to reply to seems to have been deleted. So I'll add the reply to it I wrote anyway, in case the info is useful to someone.)

"Not currently, but this evening I finished implementing a patch to bypass specific basic objectives that have been cause for concern, and remove their completion XP reward.

Fresh from the oven so needs to go through review, QA and release candidate testing, though.

To clarify, is it specifically the Basic Combat and/or Basic Prayer challenge you want to bypass?

And basic challenges don't expire, so unfortunately, no, waiting it out isn't currently an option."

Can't really comment on that. It's more of a combat council decision.

Just to note, if you've created your new ironman skiller that recently, and would rather start over than wait for a fix... as of the daily challenge update on Monday, any new accounts will get the new basic challenge onboarding, which I designed to be skiller-friendly. (You don't get any basic combat/prayer challenges in the new batch.)

As you've noted, basic challenges don't expire and can't be rerolled (AFAIK this was also the case before Monday's update).

After completing the 9 basic skilling challenges, since non-basic challenges get replaced with new ones every day, you'd be able to let the skills you don't want to engage in get replaced each day, or reroll the ones you don't want with vis wax.

Since you created your account just before Monday 15th, looks like you unfortunately still have the old set of 5 basic challenges, which include a combat challenge and a prayer challenge.

So if you stick with this account, and don't want to complete your ...

None of the 6 items you've listed above are currently substituted for ironmen.

We did run our rewards past the ironman council, but I acknowledge that some ironmen take a more hardline view than others.

So if you feel that any of the above aren't in the spirit of ironman mode via daily challenge weekly rewards, please let us know, and we'd be happy to raise them again.

The only ironman-specific feedback change so far is to decrement the size of and substitute cash bags (though that likely won't release on Monday as our team's QA are assisting another project this week).

As in D&D daily/weekly/monthly reset tokens?

First I've heard of those being an issue for ironmen. (Admittedly had my head down implementing patches the last couple days, so I may have missed a post or two.)

As far as I'm aware, we've given D&D reset tokens to ironmen in the past.

If the D&D reset tokens are contentious for ironmen and ironmen feel they aren't in the spirit of the game mode, we'd be happy to substitute them for ironmen.

Understandably cause for concern and I appreciate you raising it! Thanks for your thread and your well wishes. :)

Love being active! :D

Discussed it with Daze and we'd prefer to not implement a chat badge or titles, as it brings more visibility to an account type that's not an official game mode (and I don't think could realistically be officially recognised, since ultimately everyone's particular approach to being a pure/skiller is unique and self-imposed), and becomes one more strange thing for the casual player to grep.

Quickchat hits a nice beat for us, though, as it's relatively 'underground' and provides a way to prove the state of your account to each other in a world with XP toggles. Quickchats are also quick to implement so we can afford to add them as needed. :)

We're considering a more holistic approach to skillers of a way to turn off "direct" XP rewards (from quest completion, challenges, etc) for certain skills via Nastroth, rather than continuing to modify individual content's rewards.

Here's a link to JannaMechanic's latest proposal for direct XP blocks:

https://www.reddit.com/r/runescape/comments/pvcjsa/comment/hkubst1/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

It's buried in a reply to a thread where there's been lots of discussion around skiller/pure QoL (that's gone far beyond the original thread topic), as I thought you might find that an interesting read if you've not already been involved. :)

You've admittedly had a rather small sample size (2 occurrences) to extrapolate a drop rate.

The frequency of DTDs is closer to 1/month. They happened to fall adjacent on this occasion.

I can understand the perceived value of a deathtouched dart since it has the potential to be a big drop for minimal effort. But it's effectively a lottery ticket with extra steps.

Compared to, say, direct coin creation like a cash bag (which, BTW, we're dropping a size tier and substituting for ironmen with oddments in response to feedback), a DTD's one of the more economically stable rewards we can give - at least so I've been assured.

Boss value is measured in kills/hour and bosses are balanced around being repeatedly killed, so one free kill through a throttled non-tradeable supply that requires daily engagement to acquire contributes minimally to inflation.

It's an active reward - you have to gear up and fight the boss (albeit briefly) to get the benefit, ...

Righto, thanks so much for that extra context!

Always. I wouldn't dare to state otherwise.

Good tip, thank you!

Mod Raven has repeatedly assured us it's working as intended.

But then again, he is literally the worst kind of monster.

Righto, thank you for clarifying! :)

Thank you, but no need for the bondesign at the moment. What you've got here is nice and simple, targeted and extensible. :) Appreciate you considering the dev time incentive, though!